Talos Vulnerability Report

Summary

Multiple cross-site scripting vulnerabilities exist in the template functionality of phpGACL 3.3.7. A specially crafted HTTP request can lead to arbitrary JavaScript execution. An attacker can provide a crafted URL to trigger this vulnerability.

Tested Versions

phpGACL 3.3.7
OpenEMR 5.0.2
OpenEMR development version 6.0.0 (commit babec93f600ff1394f91ccd512bcad85832eb6ce)

Product URLs

http://phpgacl.sourceforge.net/

CVSSv3 Score

9.6 - CVSS:3.0/AV:N/AC:L/PR:N/UI:R/S:C/C:H/I:H/A:H

CWE

CWE-80 - Improper Neutralization of Script-Related HTML Tags in a Web Page (Basic XSS)

Details

phpGACL is a PHP library that allows developers to implement permission systems via a Generic Access Control List.

The latest version of this library has been found to be used in OpenEMR, as such the tests have been performed against an OpenEMR instance.

Across the whole codebase of phpGACL smarty is used for templating, however multiple variables are not escaped correctly when rendered, leading to cross-site scripting (XSS).

The following is an (incomplete) list of code paths that lead to XSS, caused by missing escape of the input parameters that can be injected by an attacker via GET or POST request. Note that other similar XSS code paths exist under the same gacl/ subdirectory.

CVE-2020-13562 - phpGACL template action parameter cross-site scripting vulnerabiliy

In admin/acl_admin.php, the GET parameter action leads to an XSS:

...
if (isset($_GET['action'])) {
        $smarty->assign('action', $_GET['action']);    [1]
}

$smarty->assign('current','acl_admin');
$smarty->assign('page_title', 'ACL Admin');

$smarty->assign('phpgacl_version', $gacl_api->get_version() );
$smarty->assign('phpgacl_schema_version', $gacl_api->get_schema_version() );
$smarty->display('phpgacl/acl_admin.tpl');             [2]
?>

At [1] the action is fetched from the query string, and passed to smarty. The template used for rendering is phpgacl/acl_admin.tpl [2]:

...
[ <a href="group_admin.php?group_type=aro&return_page={$SCRIPT_NAME}?action={$action}&acl_id={$acl_id}">Edit</a> ]
...

The line above is executed twice in the template, which renders the action argument verbatim, leading to an XSS.

Exploit Proof of Concept

This issue has been reproduced by testing against OpenEMR, which ships the latest version of phpGACL.
The following request exploits the XSS in acl_admin.php, via the action argument:

http://openemr.dev/gacl/admin/acl_admin.php?action=\"><script>alert(1)</script>

CVE-2020-13563 - phpGACL template group_id parameter cross-site scripting vulnerabiliy

In admin/assign_group.php, the GET parameter group_id leads to an XSS when an invalid or no action is specified via POST:

...
//Get group name.
$group_data = $gacl_api->get_group_data($_GET['group_id'], $group_type);
$smarty->assign('group_name', $group_data[2]);

$smarty->assign('group_id', $_GET['group_id']);                              [1]
...
$smarty->assign('group_type', $group_type);
$smarty->assign('object_type', $object_type);
$smarty->assign('return_page', $_SERVER['REQUEST_URI'] );

$smarty->assign('current','assign_group_'. $group_type);
$smarty->assign('page_title', 'Assign Group - '. strtoupper($group_type));

$smarty->assign('phpgacl_version', $gacl_api->get_version() );
$smarty->assign('phpgacl_schema_version', $gacl_api->get_schema_version() );

$smarty->display('phpgacl/assign_group.tpl');                                [2]
?>

At [1] the group_id is fetched from the query string, and passed to smarty. The template used for rendering is phpgacl/assign_group.tpl [2]:

...
        {include file="phpgacl/pager.tpl" pager_data=$paging_data link="?group_type=$group_type&group_id=$group_id&"}   [3]
          </td>
        </tr>
        <tr>
        ...
</table>
<input type="hidden" name="group_id" value="{$group_id}">   [4]

At [4] the group_id is rendered verbatim, leading to an XSS. The group_id is also passed to template pager.tpl via the “link” parameter [3], leading to another XSS:

...
      <a href="{$link}page=1">|&lt;</a> <a href="{$link}page={$paging_data.prevpage|escape:'html'}">&lt;&lt;</a>
...
      <a href="{$link}page={$paging_data.nextpage|escape:'html'}">&gt;&gt;</a> <a href="{$link}page={$paging_data.lastpageno|escape:'html'}">&gt;|</a>

Exploit Proof of Concept

This issue has been reproduced by testing against OpenEMR, which ships the latest version of phpGACL.
The following request exploits the XSS in assign_group.php, via the group_id argument:

http://openemr.dev/gacl/admin/assign_group.php?group_id="><script>alert(1)</script>

CVE-2020-13564 - phpGACL template acl_id parameter cross-site scripting vulnerabiliy

In admin/acl_admin.php, the GET parameter acl_id leads to an XSS when an invalid or no action is specified via POST:

...
        if (isset($_GET['acl_id'])) {
            $smarty->assign('acl_id', $_GET['acl_id'] );                      [1]
        }

        break;
}

//$smarty->assign('return_page', urlencode($_SERVER[REQUEST_URI]) );
if (isset($_GET['return_page'])) {
    $smarty->assign('return_page', $_GET['return_page']);
}
if (isset($_GET['action'])) {
    $smarty->assign('action', $_GET['action']);
}

$smarty->assign('current','acl_admin');
$smarty->assign('page_title', 'ACL Admin');

$smarty->assign('phpgacl_version', $gacl_api->get_version() );
$smarty->assign('phpgacl_schema_version', $gacl_api->get_schema_version() );
$smarty->display('phpgacl/acl_admin.tpl');                                     [2]
?>

At [1] the acl_id is fetched from the query string, and passed to smarty. The template used for rendering is phpgacl/acl_admin.tpl [2]:

...
[ <a href="group_admin.php?group_type=aro&return_page={$SCRIPT_NAME}?action={$action}&acl_id={$acl_id}">Edit</a> ]
...
[ <a href="group_admin.php?group_type=axo&return_page={$SCRIPT_NAME}?action={$action}&acl_id={$acl_id}">Edit</a> ]
...
<input type="hidden" name="acl_id" value="{$acl_id}">
...

In three different spots in the template, the acl_id argument is rendered verbatim, leading to an XSS.

Exploit Proof of Concept

This issue has been reproduced by testing against OpenEMR, which ships the latest version of phpGACL.
The following request exploits the XSS in acl_admin.php, via the acl_id argument:

http://openemr.dev/gacl/admin/acl_admin.php?acl_id="><script>alert(1)</script>

Timeline

2020-10-23 - Vendor Disclosure

2021-01-05 - Vendor Patched
2021-01-27 - Public Release